Keep reading
Blog/Private Credit
Distressed for control means buying enough of a struggling company’s fulcrum debt to take ownership of the business in a restructuring. Distressed for yield means buying discounted debt that should be repaid or recover close to par, and earning the coupon plus the pull to par.
The choice sets your hold period, position size, team and downside. A control deal is a multi-year equity bet on running a company. A yield trade is a one to two year credit bet on getting paid back.
This guide compares both, with numbers and a simple test for telling them apart.
Use control when you can buy the fulcrum class cheaply and you have the operating skill to run the company afterwards. Use yield when the debt sits safely above the fulcrum and the main risk is timing.
| Feature | Distressed for control | Distressed for yield |
|---|---|---|
| What you buy | The fulcrum class, usually a majority of it | Debt above the fulcrum, bought below par |
| How you get paid | Equity in the reorganised company, then a sale or IPO | Coupon plus repayment at or near par |
| Typical hold | Three years or more | Months to two years |
| Return profile | Wide range: 1.13x to 2.7x in our example | Capped near par: 1.39x in our example |
| Main risk | Valuation fights and running the business | Default or a liability management deal that subordinates you |
The control investor targets the fulcrum security. PitchBook defines it as the first part of the capital structure that does not recover in full in cash or new debt. In a Chapter 11 plan, that class usually swaps its claims for most of the new equity. Our guide to the fulcrum security in distressed restructurings walks through how to find it.
Mergers & Inquisitions describes the full path. The fund buys the fulcrum, converts it into a controlling equity stake, runs the turnaround and then sells the company or takes it public. Many of these deals run through pre-packaged bankruptcies (plans agreed with key creditors before filing).
Under Chapter 11, a class of creditors accepts a plan when holders of at least two-thirds in amount and more than half in number vote yes, according to the US Courts guide to Chapter 11. That rule drives position sizing:
The debtor has 120 days of exclusivity to file its own plan, extendable to a maximum of 18 months. A control investor needs the balance sheet and patience to sit through that period.
PitchBook notes that control investors push for a lower valuation of the reorganised company. A lower value means fewer classes are in the money, so the fulcrum class takes a larger share of the equity.
The yield investor buys debt trading well below par but sitting above the fulcrum. FTI Consulting describes distressed debt as debt yielding more than 1,000 basis points over a comparable Treasury. At that spread, a senior loan that is likely to be refinanced or repaid offers a high return without needing equity upside.
In a simple trading example from Mergers & Inquisitions, notes bought at 80 that rise to 90 produce a gain of about 13%, and a full refinancing at par produces about 25%. CAIS describes trading as the shortest and most liquid distressed approach.
Some yield investors build larger positions to gain a seat at the table without aiming to own the company. CAIS calls this active non-control. The fund seeks influence in negotiations, but its interests usually stay subordinate to the control holders, and legal costs can eat into returns.
Take one illustrative company with a $500m first-lien loan and $500m of unsecured notes. Both trades below use made-up numbers to show the mechanics.
Illustrative assumptions: you buy $50m face of the first-lien loan at 85. The loan pays a 9% coupon and is refinanced at par after two years.
Cost = $50m x 0.85 = $42.5m
Annual coupon = $50m x 9% = $4.5m
Cash received = $4.5m + $4.5m + $50m = $59m
MOIC = $59m / $42.5m = 1.39x
IRR = about 18.7%.
The return is capped by par. The price tells you how much you are paid for the risk that the loan is not repaid.
Illustrative assumptions: you buy $350m face (70%) of the notes at 40. The plan gives the unsecured class 90% of the new equity. The reorganised company is valued at $900m with $500m of debt.
Cost = $350m x 0.40 = $140m
Equity at emergence = $900m – $500m = $400m
Your stake = 70% x 90% = 63%
Value at emergence = 63% x $400m = $252m.
Upside: the turnaround works and equity is worth $600m after three years.
Exit value = 63% x $600m = $378m
MOIC = $378m / $140m = 2.7x
IRR = about 39%.
Downside: equity is still worth $250m after three years.
Exit value = 63% x $250m = $157.5m
MOIC = $157.5m / $140m = 1.13x
IRR = about 4%.
Mergers & Inquisitions calls distressed control returns a step function. The outcome jumps between scenarios depending on the plan, the valuation and the turnaround.
The two approaches need different people and different documents. You should expect these gaps:
Oaktree describes its opportunistic credit strategy as buying claims on assets at bargain prices and actively participating in restructurings.
The practical test is to run the recovery waterfall at a low enterprise value before you buy. If your class is still repaid in full, you own a yield trade. If your class receives equity, you own a control trade, whether you planned for one or not.
Choose control when:
Choose yield when:
PitchBook reports that uptiers and drop-downs can move the fulcrum. A position that looked like control can end up subordinated, and a falling enterprise value during a long process can push a class out of the money. The Serta uptier transaction shows how a priming deal shifts recoveries. Read the credit agreement for open baskets before you size either trade.
PitchBook also notes a shift toward more liability management deals and fewer classic restructurings, which means less equity changes hands. That shrinks the supply of clean control deals and raises the value of document work on yield trades.
For more on the endgame of a control deal, see our debt-for-equity swap case study, and for interviews, practise with the distressed debt case study and these restructuring interview questions. If you want structured practice on credit and restructuring models, Wall Street Oasis courses cover the core techniques step by step.
Mostly, yes. Both describe buying distressed debt without aiming to own the company. Yield usually means trading or holding paper that should be repaid near par. Active non-control is a larger position that seeks influence in negotiations, but the fund still expects to exit as a creditor and accepts that control holders lead the process.
Under Chapter 11, a class accepts a plan when holders of two-thirds in amount and more than half in number vote yes. So more than one-third by amount gives you a blocking stake, and two-thirds or more lets you deliver the class vote. Control funds usually aim for a majority of the fulcrum class.
Control has the higher upside because you own the equity of the reorganised company. In our example, the control trade made 2.7x in the upside case against 1.39x on the yield trade. The control downside was close to break-even after three years, while the yield trade depended on repayment at par.
A low valuation of the reorganised company puts fewer classes in the money, so the fulcrum class receives a larger share of the new equity. Senior creditors argue for a higher value because they want new debt or cash near par. That makes valuation a central fight in a contested plan.
Interviewers for distressed funds expect you to find the fulcrum, run a recovery waterfall and explain how you would get paid. Be ready to say whether a trade is control or yield, why, and what happens if the enterprise value falls by 20%.
Distressed for control buys the fulcrum to own the business, while distressed for yield buys debt above the fulcrum to be repaid. The right choice follows the waterfall: run it at a low enterprise value, see where your class lands, and size your stake and team to match.
P.S. To practise building recovery waterfalls and spotting the fulcrum, try the Excel Test – Distressed Debt. Our Premium Resources have more tools you may find useful, and the Private Equity Bros newsletter brings you weekly finance updates and the latest financial reports.
Join 80,000+ readers
One email a week: markets and finance news, the latest M&A deals and reports, investor biographies and deep dives.
Free forever. Unsubscribe anytime.
